EastEnders fans slam ‘worst storyline in soap history’ as they claim it ‘didn’t need’ to happen

EASTENDERS fans are fuming with soap bosses after branding a teen pregnancy twist the “worst storyline in soap history”.

Raging EastEnders viewers went online in droves, claiming the controversial plot “didn’t need to happen” and blasting writers for being “so unrealistic.”

Sign up for the EastEnders newsletter

Young woman lying on hospital bed receiving an ultrasound.

Lily discovered she was pregnant at just 12 years old – shocking viewers across the country
Stacey Slater and Lily Slater sitting on a couch.

Stacey Slater and Lily Slater sitting on a couch.

Some viewers slammed Stacey for not punishing her daughter for getting pregnantCredit: BBC
The backlash comes after Lily Slater’s pregnancy storyline sent shockwaves through Albert Square – and completely turned the Slater and Branning families’ lives upside down.

The hard-hitting plot saw Lily, played by Lillia Turner, fall pregnant at just 12, with the father revealed as Ricky Jr – sparking fierce debate among viewers and dividing opinion across the country.

Many fans praised the show for tackling a sensitive subject, while others branded it “unrealistic” and “unnecessary” for a family soap.

And some fans blasted the BBC soap for “normalising teenage pregnancy”.

Taking to an online forum on Reddit, one fan wrote: “This has bugged me for a while now – the fact that Lily, at age 12, still a kid, gave birth to a healthy baby with absolutely no problems whatsoever, for either her or her baby.

“Lilys brain was still developing yet the Slaters saw it a good idea for her to become a mother at such a young age.

“I find that absolutely disgusting, especially because Stacey was struggling to make ends meet during that time.”

Another fan added: “The issue with Lily’s pregnancy is that at no point did anyone try to engage Lily in an adult conversation about what having a baby would mean for her life.

“Lily just stomped out of every conversation she didn’t want to have, and Stacey and Martin let her.”

A third penned: “Lily had a baby at 13 with a boy her own age, nobody really bothered to explain the risks in a meaningful way and everyone’s just sort of moved on?”

A fourth commented: “I agree, it was so unrealistic and it really p***** me off. No one told her the effects it would have on her emotionally or on her body, or how it would change the course of her life.

EastEnders legend returning to Albert Square 11 years after quitting Walford – weeks after Zoe Slater & Max Branning

“She adapted so quickly and it’s irresponsible to portray a 12 year old getting pregnant this way.

“Also Ricky lives across the road and never seemed to be helping.”

Meanwhile, the new EastEnders boss, Ben Wadey, is lining up several returns.

Nicholas Bailey has reprised his role as Dr. Anthony Trueman – son of soap stalwart Patrick (Rudolph Walker) – after 11 years away.

Soap’s most harrowing teen storylines

We take a look at other harrowing teen soap storylines from soaps Coronation Street, EastEnders, Emmerdale and Hollyoaks.EastEnders fans slam 'worst storyline in soap history' as they claim it 'didn't  need' to happen | The Sun

Belle Dingle’s schizophrenia in Emmerdale – Belle’s (Eden Taylor-Draper) traumatic journey in Emmerdale took a dark turn when, after accidentally killing her best friend Gemma at just 16, her mental health began to spiral.

The storyline, which saw Belle struggling with her grief and guilt, showcased her battle with hearing Gemma’s voice inside her head, leading to a dramatic decline in her well-being.

Hannah Ashworth’s anorexia in Hollyoaks – Viewers were horrified as they watched Hannah (Emma Rigby), a seemingly innocent teen, spiral into dangerous behavior, starving herself in an attempt to achieve what she thought was the ideal body.

As Hannah’s condition worsened, the storyline became more intense, culminating in her being hospitalised for two months as she fought for her life.

Bethany Platt’s grooming ordeal in Coronation Street – Vulnerable schoolgirl, played by Lucy Fallon, was at the centre of one of Corrie’s darkest storylines to date when she fell under the spell of her older boyfriend and sexual predator.

The controversial scenes saw Nathan groom and manipulate the 16-year-old before coercing her into sleeping with his friends, with one of them raping her.

Whitney Dean’s abuse from Tony in EastEnders – Since the age of 12, she had been in a twisted relationship with her stepmum Bianca’s boyfriend, Tony King. The predator had groomed young Whit (Shona McGarty), making her believe she was in love and planning to run away with him.

On her 16th birthday, the traumatised teen finally revealed the years of abuse to Bianca. Tony was swiftly sent to prison sentenced for 13 years.

It comes as Zoe Slater (Michelle Ryan) recently made her long-awaited return to Albert Square.EastEnders fans slam 'worst storyline in soap history' as they claim it 'didn't  need' to happen | The Sun

The legendary Max Branning (Jake Wood) is also set for a return in upcoming scenes.

While Max’s son Oscar has also returned to Walford, with the role recast to Pierre Mouiller.

And Max Bowden is making a shock return as Ben Mitchell – two years after he was axed.

The actor will get a guest stint in the coming months, with a possible full-time role if all goes well.

Then-showrunner Chris Clenshaw gave Max the boot at the end of 2023 during a showdown over his party lifestyle.

But he has been given another chance by the BBC soap’s new boss.

A source said: “Ben had a list of characters he wanted to bring back and Ben Mitchell was one. It’s taken a little while to sort out but Max will be back filming on Albert Square later this year.”

In April, the new boss went to see Max, 30, in the musical Midnight Cowboy. The source added: “Ben wanted to meet Max and see where his head was at.

“Things hadn’t ended particularly well and Ben wanted to assure him this could be his fresh start.

“Max agreed to return for a short stint after Ben pitched his comeback storyline.

“But who knows what will happen? It really does depend on Max.”

Lily Slater and Ricky Mitchell walking down a street.

Lily Slater and Ricky Mitchell walking down a street.

Lily and Ricky found out they were going to be parents at just 12 years old in a shocking storylineCredit: BBC
Scene from EastEnders showing Theo Hawthorne, Lily Slater, and Stacey Slater with a baby stroller.

 

Related articles

Michelle Collins ‘gutted and worried’ as she’s forced to stop show after audience member passes out and med…

EASTENDERS legend Michelle Collins was left “gutted and worried” after being forced to halt her stage performance when an audience member collapsed mid-show. The star, 63, was appearing in a live production of…

ESCAPE PLAN UNRAVELS! EastEnders’ Oscar Spirals Into Chaos After Shocking Betrayal, What Will He Do NOW?

EastEnders fans, Oscar Branning is about to take a step he can’t undo. Fear is closing in, Oscar has no time, no plan, and someone close to…

James Bond star Colin Salmon, Absolutely Fabulous’ Harriet Thorpe, Strictly Come Dancing finalist Molly Rainford and actress Francesca Henry have joined the cast of the BBC soap opera

A new family will shortly be arriving on Albert Square as EastEnders welcomes four new cast members to the BBC soap opera. Viewers will soon be introduced to the…

Inside Soap Awards 2025 announces nominations for this year’s ceremony

Soap fans, it’s time to have your say – the Inside Soap Awards are back for their 29th year. The longlist for the 2025 ceremony has been…

ITV’s Cooking With The Stars returns tonight and EastEnders star ‘jumped at the chance’ to take part

Jack Osbourne, Kelly Hoppen, Shaun Wright-Phillips, Natalie Cassidy, Hugh Dennis, Jessica Wright, Jordan North and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu on Cooking With The Stars(Image: ITV) Cooking with the Stars…

EastEnders’ Lorraine Stanley tried weight loss jabs to lose 6.5st and one thing changed her mind

When we catch up with former EastEnders actress Lorraine Stanley at a glitzy London ball, she couldn’t look more different to Karen Taylor, the lovable yet perpetually…