The 90 Day Fiancé franchise has never been short of explosive drama, and the spin-off 90 Day Fiancé: Hunt for Love has once again delivered a shocking twist. In the latest development, cast member Cortney Reardanz has accused Colt Johnson of cheating on her—and she admits she now regrets not choosing fellow franchise star Usman “Sojaboy” Umar instead.

The revelation has sent shockwaves across the 90 Day fandom, as Cortney’s love triangle with Colt and Usman was already one of the most talked-about storylines this season. Now, her claims of betrayal are stirring up heated discussions both among castmates and fans online.

Cortney’s Allegations Against Colt

During a confessional scene on Hunt for Love, Cortney revealed her frustrations with Colt, who she says has not been fully honest in their relationship. According to her, Colt’s wandering eye became obvious just weeks after they connected.

“He told me I was the only one, but then I found out he was messaging other women,” Cortney explained tearfully. “It feels like I was just another option for him. I didn’t sign up for this show to be lied to again.”

Cortney’s words hit hard for longtime fans of the franchise, who know Colt has a complicated dating history. His relationships with Larissa Lima and Jess Caroline both ended amid accusations of dishonesty and infidelity. This latest accusation only reinforces his reputation as one of the show’s most controversial figures.

Regret Over Not Choosing Usman

Perhaps even more shocking than the cheating allegations was Cortney’s admission that she regrets not choosing Usman, the Nigerian rapper better known to 90 Day Fiancé fans as “Sojaboy.”

“I had a real connection with Usman, and now I wonder if I made the wrong choice,” Cortney confessed. “He made me feel valued and respected, and I can’t stop thinking about what could have been.”

Usman, who previously appeared on 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days with Lisa Hamme and later with Kimberly Menzies, has become one of the franchise’s most polarizing figures. Despite his rocky past relationships, many viewers agree that his charm and persistence make him an appealing match for someone like Cortney.

Fan Reactions: Team Cortney or Team Colt?

The drama immediately sparked heated debates across social media. Fans have taken to Twitter, Reddit, and Instagram to weigh in on whether Cortney is justified in her claims—and whether she should pursue a second chance with Usman.

One fan tweeted: “Colt cheating again? Are we surprised? Cortney deserves way better.” Another wrote: “Imagine leaving Sojaboy for Colt Johnson. Yeah, I’d regret it too.”

However, not everyone sided with Cortney. Some viewers suggested she may be using Colt’s reputation against him to secure more screen time. “She knew what she was signing up for. Colt’s history is public,” one fan argued.

Colt’s Side of the Story

As expected, Colt has denied the cheating accusations. In a preview clip for the next episode, Colt is seen confronting Cortney, insisting that she is overreacting.

“I didn’t cheat on you. Messaging fans is not cheating,” Colt defends himself. “I’ve been honest about who I am, and if you can’t handle that, then maybe I’m not the problem.”

His explanation has only fueled more debates, with some fans calling his actions disrespectful regardless of whether they constitute “cheating.”

Usman Reacts

Adding even more fuel to the fire, Usman shared a cryptic Instagram post shortly after the episode aired. Posting a selfie with the caption “Some choices cannot be undone” and a winking emoji, fans immediately speculated that he was throwing shade at Cortney’s decision.

In the comments, followers begged Cortney to “give Usman another chance,” while others warned her to be cautious given Usman’s past rocky relationships.

What’s Next for Cortney?

With emotions running high, the big question is whether Cortney will cut ties with Colt for good and possibly reconsider a future with Usman. TLC has not confirmed if the show will follow up on this potential reunion, but given the fan interest, producers may be tempted to explore it further.

Cortney, meanwhile, hinted that she is taking time for herself before making any big decisions. “I need to figure out what’s best for me,” she told producers. “I can’t keep repeating the same mistakes.”

Final Thoughts

The love triangle between Cortney, Colt, and Usman has become one of the juiciest storylines on 90 Day Fiancé: Hunt for Love. With accusations of cheating, public regret, and cryptic social media posts, the drama shows no signs of slowing down.

For fans, the situation raises larger questions about trust, second chances, and whether reality TV stars can truly find love under the spotlight. One thing is certain: Cortney’s romantic journey is far from over—and viewers will be tuning in eagerly to see how it unfolds.